Home Innovation What Is the Artistic Process? The Stages, and Where Real Practice Diverges

11-min readWhat Is the Artistic Process? The Stages, and Where Real Practice Diverges

0
<span class="wtr-time-wrap before-title"><span class="wtr-time-number">11</span>-min read</span>What Is the Artistic Process? The Stages, and Where Real Practice Diverges

Concentrated Wisdom Editorial Team researches, writes, and fact-checks this guide against primary sources before publication.

This article is for informational purposes only and isn’t a substitute for personalized professional advice.

The artistic process most commonly taught has four stages: preparation, incubation, illumination, and verification, a model first proposed by psychologist Graham Wallas in his 1926 book The Art of Thought. Real working artists describe a looser, looping version of this same model in practice, moving back and forth between stages rather than through them once, with illumination typically arriving during repetition rather than as a sudden bolt from nowhere. This guide covers the four stages as originally defined, where practice actually diverges from the textbook version, and how to use the model to diagnose which stage is actually stuck.

what is the artistic process graph

The artistic process is most commonly described using a four-stage model: preparation, incubation, illumination, and verification. This model was first proposed by psychologist Graham Wallas in his 1926 book The Art of Thought, making it one of the earliest formal accounts of the creative process and one still widely referenced in design and creativity research today. Preparation is gathering information and defining the problem. Incubation is stepping back from the problem to allow unconscious processing to continue. Illumination is the moment of insight, commonly called the aha moment. Verification is evaluating, testing, and refining the resulting idea. In practice, working artists describe this model less as a straight line and more as a loop, moving back into preparation or incubation repeatedly within a single piece, and illumination is frequently reported arriving in the middle of ordinary, repetitive work on the piece rather than as a sudden, unearned flash of inspiration. Understanding which of the four stages a creative block actually sits in makes it possible to apply a targeted response instead of a generic one.

The artistic process most commonly taught has four stages, in this order: preparation, incubation, illumination, and verification, a model first proposed by psychologist Graham Wallas in his 1926 book The Art of Thought.

The model reads like a straight staircase on paper. In practice it behaves more like a spiral staircase viewed from above, the same four steps returning again and again rather than a single climb to the top.

The Four-Stage Model

Preparation

Preparation is gathering raw material and defining the actual problem before attempting to solve it. This stage covers research, reference-gathering, sketching, and the unglamorous work of figuring out what the piece is actually trying to do, not yet trying to do it.

Diagram of the four-stage artistic process, preparation, incubation, illumination, and verification

This is also the stage skipped most often by anyone in a hurry to produce something. A painter skipping preparation starts mixing color before deciding what the piece needs to say. A writer skipping it starts drafting scenes before knowing what the story’s actual tension is. Skipped preparation doesn’t disappear, it resurfaces later as a stall in one of the other three stages instead.

Incubation

Incubation is stepping back from a problem to allow unconscious processing to continue without direct, effortful attention. Wallas proposed this stage roughly a century ago, and it has since become one of the most studied parts of the model, with modern neuroscience research directly supporting it. Studies on the brain’s default mode network, the network active during rest and mind-wandering, have found that successful incubation involves real coordination between the default mode network and the brain’s controlled-attention systems, not simply idle time, a finding that gives Wallas’s century-old stage genuine modern neurological backing.

Illumination

Illumination is the moment of insight, commonly called the aha moment, where the pieces gathered in preparation and processed during incubation suddenly connect into a workable idea.

Illumination is also the stage that gets the most cultural attention and the least accurate portrayal. Popular accounts treat it as a rare, almost mystical event, a bolt of lightning that arrives to the lucky or the gifted. The actual research and the actual working-artist accounts covered in the next section describe something more ordinary: a connection that was always available once enough preparation and processing had happened, surfacing at a specific, describable moment rather than materializing from nothing.

Verification

Verification is evaluating, testing, and refining the idea that illumination produced. This is the stage the popular version of the model gets skipped over most often, since an insight is not yet a finished piece, it’s a starting point that still has to survive contact with the actual work.

Related: Creativity & Innovation

Related: Artistic Temperament

Where Real Artists’ Process Diverges

Nonlinear Looping Between Stages

Wallas’s own model was never strictly meant as a rigid, one-way sequence, and later scholarship revisiting his original text has noted the four stages were intended more loosely than the popularized diagram version suggests, but the diagram version is what stuck, and it implies a single clean pass through four boxes.

Explainer graphic showing how the real artistic process loops between stages instead of moving in a straight line

Real practice rarely works that way. A piece in verification regularly reveals a gap that sends the artist back to preparation for more reference material, or back to incubation because the current solution isn’t actually working. A single painting, story, or piece of music might cycle through all four stages several times before it’s finished, each pass narrower and more specific than the last.

A short story provides a clean example. A writer might finish preparation by researching a setting, reach illumination on a plot twist, then hit verification only to discover the twist requires information the reader was never given, which sends the piece straight back to preparation for a new pass, not forward to publication. The four-stage model still applies, it just applies more than once, and treating a single pass through all four stages as the finish line is where the textbook version and the lived version part ways most sharply.

The Role of Unglamorous Repetition the Model Underplays

A recurring pattern shows up across interviews with working artists describing how illumination actually arrives: it rarely shows up while staring at a blank page waiting for inspiration. It shows up mid-repetition, in the middle of the fifteenth practice sketch, the third rewrite of a scene, or a routine studio session that wasn’t expected to produce anything notable. The insight interrupts ordinary, already-in-progress work far more often than it arrives to a person who is simply waiting for it.

This matters because the popular shorthand version of the model, wait for inspiration to strike, then execute, inverts the actual order most working artists describe. The repetition isn’t what happens after the idea arrives, it’s frequently the condition that produces the idea in the first place.

Related: 7 Steps of Creative Process

Using the Model in Your Own Work

Recognizing Which Stage You’re Stuck In

Most generic advice for feeling stuck assumes the same problem every time, but the four stages fail in different ways and need different fixes. A stall in preparation feels like not having enough to work with. A stall in incubation feels like forcing a solution that keeps refusing to click. A stall before illumination feels like having all the pieces but no connection between them. A stall in verification feels like having an idea that won’t survive being finished.

Practical Unsticking Tactics Per Stage

  • Stuck in preparation: gather more raw material deliberately, references, research, or reps, before attempting a solution at all
  • Stuck in incubation: step away from the problem on purpose, with a real return time set in advance so stepping away doesn’t quietly turn into avoidance
  • Stuck before illumination: keep doing repetitive, low-stakes work on the piece rather than waiting idle, since insight tends to interrupt ongoing work rather than arrive to a blank page
  • Stuck in verification: separate evaluating the idea from generating it, and get one outside reaction before deciding whether the piece actually works

Diagnostic graphic for identifying which stage of the artistic process a creative block is actually stuck in

The diagnostic value of the four-stage model isn’t in following it in order, it’s in naming, honestly, which stage a given block is actually in, since the wrong fix applied to the right stage rarely helps.

Related: The Seven Stages of Creativity, From Preparation to Verification, Creative Flow

Frequently Asked Questions

What are the four stages of the artistic process?

The four stages, as originally proposed by psychologist Graham Wallas in his 1926 book The Art of Thought, are preparation, incubation, illumination, and verification. Preparation gathers information, incubation allows unconscious processing, illumination is the moment of insight, and verification tests and refines the resulting idea.

Who created the four-stage model of the artistic process?

Psychologist Graham Wallas proposed the four-stage model, preparation, incubation, illumination, and verification, in his 1926 book The Art of Thought. It remains one of the earliest and most widely referenced formal models of the creative process in design and creativity research.

Is the artistic process always linear?

No. While the four-stage model is often diagrammed as a straight sequence, working artists commonly describe looping back through earlier stages multiple times within a single piece, and illumination frequently arrives during repetitive work rather than as an isolated flash of inspiration.

What does incubation mean in the artistic process?

Incubation is the stage where a person steps back from a problem and lets unconscious processing continue without direct, effortful attention. Neuroscience research on the brain’s default mode network has found real support for this stage, showing measurable brain-network coordination during successful incubation rather than simple idle time.

What is the verification stage of the artistic process?

Verification is the final stage, where the idea produced by illumination gets evaluated, tested, and refined into a finished piece. It’s frequently the least discussed stage in popular accounts of the artistic process, even though an unfinished or untested idea is not yet the same thing as completed work.